In a letter written in 1817 to his brother the romantic poet John Keats referring to Shakespeare talked about a special ability he called “negative capability”. According to Keats Shakespeare had this ability to suspend his values, assumptions, beliefs and expectations and stay in a condition of “not knowing” without reaching anxiously for quick fixes or solutions. Keats wrote:
What if we state that learning—and especially learning leadership—is about stepping outside the limits of your current thinking by developing this “negative capability”?
Keats’ negative capability provides a vocabulary for productive disorientation in the journey of leadership. A leadership development program that would create and foster this negative capability would focus on creating a new mindset, one that allows one to thrive in the absence of certainty, with incomplete data, and imperfect skills. The underlying belief here is that becoming a high-performing leader is also about learning how to withstand the anxiety of being in that state of not -knowing productively.
Fostering negative capability, cultivating the ability to have a “beginner’s mind”—the childlike curiosity to meet the challenges of leadership without preconceived assumptions, beliefs, expectations or judgments, is akin to learning a new language.
You might realize that—in learning Spanish for example—you find language and grammar relatively easy. The tougher work would most likely turn out to be mastering other completely unpredictable skills like:
- Learning to simplify a phrase to minimize mistakes
- Learning to deal with your own sense of incompetence in public
- Learning to listen for new sounds
And most importantly, learning to do all this without panicking, or “without irritable reaching after fact and reason.”
You would soon discover tha—beyond your knowledge of Spanish grammar and vocabulary—the practice of those new skills requires the ability to manage the frustration of not succeeding. Even more importantly than your knowledge of grammar and language, this ability will become key to your success.
Many quit learning languages for that very reason: the stress of not-knowing or of looking stupid is too hard to take. What if we were to teach leaders to handle that stress better? Done successfully, the development of this negative capability will allow people to be willing to stick with it until they become more adept at that tougher work. in this perspective, orchestrating leadership at work resembles cultivating ion ourself and others thIS ‘negative capability”.
In a nutshell teaching leaders Keats’ negative capability would be about “learning how to learn.” This means realizing at a personal level that broader learning is a direct result of the willingness to suffer the pain of adopting a new and disorienting “way of being” in service of your purpose.
No easy task.
Adriano understands how to increase your returns on leadership. He works with professionals in world-class organizations that include Philip Morris, Microsoft, the World Bank, Johns Hopkins University, the US Marine Corps, the State Department and NASA. A skilled experiential educator with corporate leadership experience, he is the Founder & Principal Consultant of ParticipAction Consulting, Inc., a firm committed to help clients redefine change, collaboration and power in their organizations. He co-authored "Teachable Moments of Leadership" with Jill Hufnagel in 2016, on a learning methodology that gets results by going from PowerPoint to …powerful!